I finally finished this book! It’s taken me several months to get through it (it’s a chunky one) and like @MeganB I’m glad it’s over too. Not because it was bad, but because it was super long and a heavy lift (physically and intellectually). Now I need to move on to something a little lighter for next book club.
Book Title and Author:
Drawing Down the Moon: Witches Druids, Goddess-Worshippers and Other Pagans in America
by Margot Adler
Status? : Finished
My overall rating of the book : 9/10
How does this book relate to my magickal practice?:
This book helped me to reflect on and define my pagan practices. Especially in the first couple of chapters, I was marking up this book with passages that I related to deeply.
My personal thoughts/opinions:
Adler’s style of writing is beautiful. This is partially a book about witchcraft and also a book about witchcraft traditions, mostly Wiccan, and the history of these traditions in the U.S.
Personally, I truly enjoyed the following chapters:
- Paganism and Prejudice
- A Religion Without Converts
- The Pagan World View
- The Craft Today
- Magic and Ritual
- Living on the Earth
This book gives a good historical account of witchcraft in the U.S. It’s clear she did her research with over 100 pages of resources, notes, and bibliography. In order to write this book she did extensive interviews and surveys with practicing witches in the 1970s and details rituals and celebrations in multiple chapters. Fortunately or unfortunately, many of this smaller splinter groups/traditions have disbanded since the publication of this book and others (not mentioned) have popped up. The witchcraft traditions are constantly evolving and forming.
My interest was less the history parts of the book (although I think having the background and reading it was important - although a bit dry and boring) and more the background, beliefs, and practices described in the early chapters. There she uses the historical research and compiles the interview data to come through with summaries of what many witches and Pagans believe and practice. I think these chapters hold very much true to today, even though the first edition of the book was written in 1979. Most current readers might find issue with the focus on Wicca v. traditional or other types of witchcraft, but that was what she found at the time to be practices with the people she interviewed and surveyed. She also briefly describes druids and other goddess-worshippers but not enough in my mind to be included in the title of the book.
I loved looking through the Appendices through the sections on Ritual and Resources. Many of the groups and festivals were no longer in existence (makes sense with the date of the book) but some were including one in Minnesota that I began following on youtube, Circle Sanctuary, and a festival in Illinois, Pan-Pagan Festival which is coming up in August. Maybe I’ll attend? It’s listed as one of the oldest Pagan festivals in the U.S. I never heard of these “more local” festivals before, only Mystic South in Atlanta (which was not mentioned in the book). So this text gave me some good resources to explore, including more local community based events.
I love personally how she brings in Paganism and Unitarian Universalism (UU). Especially how in 1995, “the UUA embraced the Pagan nature traditions by adopting a sixth source to draw from: ‘Spiritual teachings of Earth-centered traditions which celebrate the sacred circle of life and instruct us to live in harmony with the rhythms of nature.’” This essentially meant that many Pagans in the U.S. could find a UU church as a welcoming home for them. And then the Covenant of UU Pagans was formed to create UU Pagan groups and these are still in effect today. I’m trying to influence my small Pagan group to become a CUUPs group.
I loved to hear the trajectory of witchcraft in her opinion since the most recent edition was written in 2006, where she is excited about Pagans/witches who are:
-
active in interfaith efforts
-
growth in Pagan Studies at the academic level
-
increase in Pagan Seminaries like Cherry Hill
-
focus on children and families in Paganism
Overall, I really connected with this book and even though I don’t consider myself a Wiccan, I appreciated it fully.
An interesting quote from the book: " "
“Here’s the big question: Has the polythesistic affirmation of diversity come at a time when most people increasingly fear complexity and accept authoritarian solutions?”
p. 34-35
All in all, would I recommend this book?:
Yes, but be ready to skip chapters (if you are less interested in history) and realize that it is a dated historical text.