Have you ever "compared" your decks?

Hey Lovelies :waving_hand:t4:

Another random one from me :see_no_evil_monkey: I did a spread earlier, and one of the cards is quite different when compared to the RWS deck, and it feels different too. You know how each deck has their own energy and personality? Well, I was wondering what would happen if I took cards from one deck and then pulled the exact same cards from another deck to see if the message felt different, as well as looked different.

I compared 4 cards from RWS deck and the Age of Aquarius deck - and I didn’t pull these by the way, I chose them, how bummed would I be if I pulled these cards lol. But that’s my point - the AoA deck seems to be so much more ethereal and hopeful than the RWS…or is it just me?

Btw the cards are 8 Swords, 10 Swords, Death and The Tower. I plan to get all of my decks out and start comparing as soon as I have the time, but I just wondered if anyone agreed, or am I seeing what I want to see?

x Blessed Be x

14 Likes

I see what you are saying. The pics themselves have a different feel, adding to the personality of the deck. Softer colors on the AoA deck and the whispiness of the art are more gentle looking than the RWS, offering more of a sense of hope. You can use this to your benefit or to your detriment, depending where you take the messages within yourself. Some may take the images of ethereal beauty as a sign of weakness, if they require strictness in order to convince themselves to act. Thus, if you forgive the alusion, heaven is in the eye or heart of the beholder.

This poses the questions of what is in your heart?What do you require? How do you define what you see- in general as well as in the images of the cards? These questions help refine personal values as well as assisting in defining yourself, your definitions of good and evil, and where you are headed in life as well as after.

Good call, @Nikki-Phoenix! Keep up the good work!

10 Likes

Exactly! The hope is more obvious in the AoA deck, but at the same time, it feels more like the joy and empowerment of the RWS 10 of Cups to me; completion of the cycle, harmonius union of thought and emotions, but also a subtle suggestion of a deep spiritual awakening of the soul.

Some may, but I don’t lol; funnily enough, I pulled the AoA 10 Swords a couple of weeks ago and I felt a sense of RWS dread. But it turned out that the result was more like this card, which was a lovely surprise. Thanks for replying!

x Blessed Be x

11 Likes

Yes. Totally agree that some non-RWS are great. One of my problems with some of the non-RWS decks is the card is hard if not impossible to connect to its meaning. Here is an example I’ve used previously. This card is supposed to represent regret/grief/loss (among others). The author did put the keywords on the card but the picture is from Mars. And… is that Bart on her arm?

Other, non-RWS, decks do fine - I think your AoA deck could work for me. But just splashing an obscure picture on the card interferes with my intuition.

EDIT: Having said all that here is an RWS card that has always confused me. The IV of Swords. To me, this guy is kaput, has shed his mortal coil, is no more (apologies to Monty Python). Instead he is supposed to represent rest and relaxation. Some books explain carefully he is around his family and basking in a job well done. I think he is laying on a coffin after being embalmed.

EDIT 3 (I’m at it again)

Here is my IV of Swords (AI and modified) It needs work but since I made it, I can suspend disbelief to think of peace (maybe through strength) and calm. At least there isn’t a dead body there :rofl:

9 Likes

I have to agree with you on this one. I’ve been to too many French Cathedrals to not have seen this image as a tomb. Does anybody still consider crossing the rainbow bridge as “going to one’s eternal rest” anymore?

As for the pic of the tattoo, I’ve heard many say that a tattoo is permanent: think twice about getting a temporary fad etched permanently: you may regret it. It does apply, but you have to be among a certain crowd to get the message. Many people just don’t travel in those kinds of circles, that’s all.

I met a man at a homeless shelter who had tattooed an upside down cross on his forehead. No one wanted to sit with him, let alone hire him to work or let him live nearby. I sat silently, and felt a sense of gratitude emanating from him until someone came along and shooed him away. We gave each other looks of desperation, but he left peacefully. I never saw him again after that. He seemed like a nice guy. I sincerely hope he has found happiness!

10 Likes

That is Bart’s demonic cousin. And I totally can’t unsee that :flushed_face: :see_no_evil_monkey::rofl: and that card is deffo a doozy lol!

x Blessed Be x

9 Likes

I pulled 10 of swords from 2 of my non RWS decks. Neither of them look appealing to me. :rofl::rofl::rofl:

Ten of swords from the dark tarot deck means time to accept a relationship or situation is ruined and it’s time to move on.

Ten of daggers from the macabre tarot deck means your pain and suffering has reached its end. It’s time to move on.

Both similar meanings. My cards may all look similar since I choose the darker side. I do have one RWS deck that I use when doing readings for others.

10 Likes

Now that is fascinating that they’re both similar meanings!

To be honest, 10 of Swords is one of those cards which confusdicate me because it’s just not like the others! Doesn’t exactly inspire the completion of a cycle in a positive way, according to RWS, completion of any Air cycle is always mostly negative with a sliver of hope on the horizon. Ah well, I guess they had their reasons lol.

x Blessed Be x

9 Likes

Nikki-Phoenix

I was raised in the 60’s and have a deep seated issue with rules.
So I can bend and sometimes ignore the them.

Tarot is inturpratational and thought prevoking. Just because a card seems filled with doom and gloom, doesn’t make it so (face up or face down show oposite meanings). It’s change.

It isn’t meant to frighten, it’s suggestions. I never ask the seeker what’s their issue. I ask them to think deeply about what’s troubling them. That way, they aren’t swaying my thouhts.
When I do a reading, it’s usually a 3 card spread. If, after reading the first three, if I feel the need, I draw another card to clarify.
I offer suggestion, not cold hard facts, that comes from Deity.

Be kind with yourself. Sometimes a deck is contrary or just doesn’t you. I had a Dragon Tarot deck that gave non-sence answers. I blessed it, I consecrated it, begged it and finally threatened to drown it. (And its little dog too. Cackle, Cackle. :witch_moon:)
But my neice asked if she could try and that recalcitrint deck worked perfect for her. So the choice was made, I gave the deck to her. It just didn’t like me. But when I went back to my favorite deck, it made total sense again.

Blessed be’
Garnet elder mother

11 Likes

I love when cards are confusing :laughing: it makes you think really hard about what the artist and creator could have possibly meant! Tens are seen as the end of a cycle, for sure – I see the 10 of Swords not as an end of turmoil, but as rock-bottom. Nothing else “bad” can happen because it’s all already happened. The only way to go now is up!


Now you’re making me want to get all my cards out and compare… :joy: I do this often, actually, I just never really thought about it.

There are several cards I look for when I buy a new deck, so I went through my decks to grab those cards out of each one. They are The Tower, The Moon, The High Priestess, Temperance, and the Three of Swords. Yes, I know – all heavy cards! I look for these specifically, especially if I can browse the deck before I buy it, because if I can connect to the heaviness of the cards in the artwork, I can usually connect to everything else the deck has to offer. If I find The Tower too “soft”, or The Moon too “light”, then I know the deck probably isn’t for me. Of course, it all depends… :laughing:

Here are those cards from my tarot decks. There are four “exceptions” to my choosing these decks – I didn’t buy the last four. Two of them were sent to me by the creator, one was a gift for Christmas, and the other was my very first deck that was given to me by a family member.


From top to bottom, these are The Traditional Manga Tarot, The Somnia Tarot, The This Might Hurt Tarot, and The Shadowscapes Tarot. Below, I’ve got some close-up pictures of each deck.

These are all decks I purchased myself. They each have their own “flavor”, I’d say. For example, The Somnia Tarot is a deck I use when I’m struggling with a more mental or logical issue. It’s also the one I gravitate toward when I’m having a depression episode. The photographer who created this deck used his night terrors and sleep paralysis episodes as inspiration for the cards.

He also didn’t use any special effects or digital manipulation to get the photos, either. Everything is done manually – so, yes, there was actually a dollhouse on fire on his back for The Tower! The Somnia Tarot is one of the more interesting decks I have. I did a video walkthrough here if you’re interested, and I highly encourage you to check out the photographer - Nicholas Bruno - if that’s something you like.

The other deck links are here if you’re interested.


From top to bottom, these are Mother Tarot, Dark Days Tarot, Nightmare Before Christmas Tarot, and Hanson-Roberts Tarot.

Now, these four decks are ones that I did not purchase myself, nor did I have the option to look through for the cards I like before receiving them. While I do connect with these decks for different reasons, the five cards alone don’t necessarily give me the feeling I look for.

Out of these four, I tend to use Mother Tarot and Dark Days Tarot the least. They’re difficult for me to shuffle, and I only feel drawn to the art at very specific times. The Nightmare Before Christmas Tarot is also a deck I’m only drawn to on specific occasions. Despite being more traditional, I actually really enjoy the Hanson-Roberts Tarot. The cards are smaller and easy to shuffle, and the artwork isn’t standard, but it still follows the traditional themes of Pamela Coleman-Smith’s original art.

Here are links to those decks, if you’re interested.


Looking at all of the cards together, you can see themes and symbols that cross all the artwork. For example, The Tower depicts a large structure experiencing a catastrophe. For some, that’s a lightning strike. For another, it’s an erupting volcano. However, some of the cards are more ethereal and “light” than others – I would never pick up The Shadowscapes Deck if I needed a blunt and to-the-point answer. The artwork is flowy and the readings tend to be more flowery and poetic.

I have to say, I really enjoyed this little exercise and getting all the cards out – thanks for the inspiration, @Nikki-Phoenix :smiling_face_with_three_hearts:

10 Likes

Lots of beautiful decks here :open_mouth: I love them. Tarot idiot here :rofl: but I do compare different runes sets. The gemstones runes are pretty but their energy is heavy, however ones of natural wood connect very quickly with spirit, as do the paper/card types (also wood), which may link it to Yydrasill (Norse tree of life), that’s just my theory being it too is a tree :person_shrugging::laughing:.

I also don’t gel well with rune card imagery set in the Viking era as I feel the gods are in the here and now, I prefer it, when the rune cards have either a modern image to reflect the rune meaning or no imagery at all.

Just me :person_shrugging::rofl:

10 Likes

Snap! :clap:t4:

I don’t think I made myself clear, my bad; the 10 of Swords doesn’t scare me at all, just like Death or The Tower don’t scare me. I don’t necessarily see the “bad” cards as bad, I think they are the balance echoed throughout life - I tend to think it’s our perception of change as a bad thing (we humans love familiar) that makes people fear some cards.

I literally meant it confuses me because it doesn’t fit the pattern of the other cards; they all represent different stages of a cycle from 1 to 10, right? All the other 10s in the RWS are indicative of a positive end to that cycle, even if there are warnings to heed…except the 10 of Swords. That card, to me, suggests that any cycle we go through in the Air element will end with us being at rock bottom - do you see what I mean @Garnet @MeganB?

I totally agree, it’s just what I said above - those 10 swords could’ve been sailing out to sea, or stuck in the ground and he’s sailing off to the next cycle…I hope I’m making sense! And you’re very welcome, I’m glad it inspired you!

Finally got some time to compare mine, and as I was going through them I noticed other cards that often differe greatly between decks, like The Devil for example. Anyway, here are the rest of my 8 & 10 of swords, Death and The Tower:


Top to bottom, the decks are Rainbow, Universal Celtic and Stained Glass tarot decks.


Seemed rude to not include the fun decks, Marvel and 8-Bit :blush:

Honestly, I’d forgotten about the Rainbow deck and when I finished this I did a simple week spread, 1 card plus 1 clarifier for each day and wow…

One day, I intend to gather my fave cards from each deck and compare those…could be interesting!

x Blessed Be x

8 Likes

I’ve just had arrive a demonic/angel oracle deck. I had the demonic before, and even though I didn’t like it (the pictures aren’t very colourful) it liked me and still does. So I thought I would get the complete set where you connect with both demon (shade) and angel (light) energy.

Again, not a colourful deck but the depth of energy is a) unsettling and b) tingly and exciting :flushed_face::partying_face:

It works with the goetia demons and their opposite angels, aswell as incorporating sigil Magick. Using your date of birth, you find the three angels that are your guardians and the one demon, then work with them and the cards.

We’ll see how I go, but I do love working in demonolatry and to include angelic divine aswell - wow. :wink:

I have seen some tarot readers mix decks and then pull cards - not sure how this works. But it looks interesting :grin:

Skal :clinking_beer_mugs:

7 Likes

Do let us know how you get on! I admit, I did a little eye fornicating with this deck once upon a time, but I’m pretty sure I’m not ready for it :see_no_evil_monkey::rofl:

Same! I mean I get it in theory, but I don’t know, it just doesn’t feel right to me lol. I do love combo spreads though, e.g. doing a spread with tarot and then with oracle or angel therapy and shadow work, and seeing how the messages line up - or not lol! I must admit, they usually do line up, and I love finding out which light areas I need to focus on and which shadow areas too.

x Blessed Be x

8 Likes

Well I’ve just found my first two angels, and it’s weird how they match my personality and spirit outlook :thinking: found my demon too, a nature animal loving demon who loves divination - so me. Spooky this :flushed_face: Got one more angel to figure out, my soul guardian, but so far these card are uncanny. :partying_face: Have a lovely evening. :green_heart:

Skal :clinking_beer_mugs:

8 Likes

8 Likes

Ahh okay, I think I see what you mean now! You’re saying that the way the swords are presented in the image doesn’t give you the sense that it’s a rock-bottom-only-way-is-up type of situation, right? I can kinda see that!

8 Likes

I pulled cards from most of the decks I have (missed two that were downstairs and I was too lazy to get them).



10 of Swords



The Fool



Death


Strength

I find that with most of my decks, I know the meanings of the cards (based on the name or pips) well enough that I can see elements of the meaning in the Non-RWS decks without any issue - the exception being the Mythos Tarot Deck. Its art is goooooorgeous, but even knowing Greek mythology, I find the deck non-intuitive. It’s more of a deck to connect to or honor a specific god/goddess.

8 Likes

@Artemisia - Nice collection. I had to expand the pictures a couple of times to appreciate them. I have 15 decks or so but I only relate to two or three. It’s entirely possible I’ll move to some of the more esoteric (non RWS) as I get more familiar.

@Nikki-Phoenix and all… The RWS swords suit has given me a bit of trouble. I have a hard time relating to several of them. Maybe it is my tendency to think of a sword as more positive than I should. In this case, some of the non-RWS examples seem easier to intuit.

7 Likes

I’ve noticed something similar. Are we sure Swords are Air and Wands are Fire? To me it seems the opposite. Yeah, yeah. I’m a weirdo.

7 Likes